Some people say that Sonic X is considered canon, but others disregard the archie comics and some of the other Sonic storylines. I was going to address this in the Silaze thread, but I think that poor thread has been derailled too many times. *pets the thread*
So I decided to start a new one, what do you guys consider canon? Here's what I have to say:
If we're gonna count Sonic X, we might as well count Archie, SatAm, Sonic Underground and all the other Sonic universes out there. I don’t know about the rest of the forum, but I consider those alternate realities. Sure they’re canon in a sense, since they’re published and licensed by Sega, but they’re canon to their own universe and not canon to the games. Sonic X was based off the games, but it wasn’t necessarily the games either. Chris and Cosmo for example, are exclusive to Sonic X, but have nothing to do with the games; just like Princess Sally and the freedom fighters is canon to SatAm and Archie, Sonia/Manic to Sonic Underground, and Scratch and Grounder to Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog, and Porker Lewis, Johnny, Dr. Zachary and Ebony are canon in the Sonic the comic Fleetway Universe respectively.
I'm going strictly by the games. Sure Sonic cares about Amy and he puts up with her because she's his friend. Nothing more.
Now, this does get tricky because you could say the old Game Gear games had their own canonization since nothing in the Game Gear games and the Genesis games really added up. Of course, Sonic CD didn’t correspond with Sonic 1, 2, 3 and S&K either. I always kind of assumed that Sonic Adventure picked up after Sonic 3 & K and possibly Knuckles Chaotix, and Sonic CD might’ve happened prior to the events in Sonic 2 because Sonic 2 leads directly into Sonic 3, or Sonic CD could’ve happened after Sonic 3 & K story wise (I’m aware of it being developed along side Sonic 2)
But then again it all depends on what you want to consider canon. I don’t necessarily consider Sonic Spinball canon but the SatAM fans probably would just because of the brief appearance in the games by Bunnie and Sally. (Bunnie I wouldn’t mind seeing in the games though because her robotic limbs could really pwn in a game)
So I decided to start a new one, what do you guys consider canon? Here's what I have to say:
If we're gonna count Sonic X, we might as well count Archie, SatAm, Sonic Underground and all the other Sonic universes out there. I don’t know about the rest of the forum, but I consider those alternate realities. Sure they’re canon in a sense, since they’re published and licensed by Sega, but they’re canon to their own universe and not canon to the games. Sonic X was based off the games, but it wasn’t necessarily the games either. Chris and Cosmo for example, are exclusive to Sonic X, but have nothing to do with the games; just like Princess Sally and the freedom fighters is canon to SatAm and Archie, Sonia/Manic to Sonic Underground, and Scratch and Grounder to Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog, and Porker Lewis, Johnny, Dr. Zachary and Ebony are canon in the Sonic the comic Fleetway Universe respectively.
I'm going strictly by the games. Sure Sonic cares about Amy and he puts up with her because she's his friend. Nothing more.
Now, this does get tricky because you could say the old Game Gear games had their own canonization since nothing in the Game Gear games and the Genesis games really added up. Of course, Sonic CD didn’t correspond with Sonic 1, 2, 3 and S&K either. I always kind of assumed that Sonic Adventure picked up after Sonic 3 & K and possibly Knuckles Chaotix, and Sonic CD might’ve happened prior to the events in Sonic 2 because Sonic 2 leads directly into Sonic 3, or Sonic CD could’ve happened after Sonic 3 & K story wise (I’m aware of it being developed along side Sonic 2)
But then again it all depends on what you want to consider canon. I don’t necessarily consider Sonic Spinball canon but the SatAM fans probably would just because of the brief appearance in the games by Bunnie and Sally. (Bunnie I wouldn’t mind seeing in the games though because her robotic limbs could really pwn in a game)